|Challenges|| Change-Up (final)|
|Eliminations||1 (0 wins, 1 loss)|
Bio: Shay is a familiar face within the C&R Game Shows group. Although familiar with the game, this may be seen as a disadvantage as she is coming into the game with a huge target on her back. Will Shay be able to overcome the target on her back and make it to the end?
|6||Walk the Plank||WIN|
Note: After Shay's elimination in Episode 4 she was brought back as a replacement after the departure of Mojo725.
Bio: Shay is definitely known to have played an interesting first season. She went through an extremely rocky road: from losing an elimination, to being brought back and getting a strong partner, to losing that partner and having to work with a brand new person in the final... She definitely had quite the experience. Despite all the things thrown at her, Shay was still able to achieve second place and is now returning on the All-Stars team for the win this time.
|4||Weight For Me||Aidan||Diamond||OUT|